Approve a specification, not just a sample
By Muhammad Shakil, Founder & CEO ·
A sample can look perfect and the factory may still be unable to reproduce it across a commercial shipment. Sample approval and production inspection are two different things.
Can a sample pass and the bulk order still fail?
Yes. One order was for about 18,000 navy cotton bath towels, 70 × 140 cm, at a target 550 GSM. The pre-production sample was approved: the colour matched the buyer’s reference, the towel felt right and the first physical tests were satisfactory.
The problem appeared in the final production checks. The towels had been dyed in several lots, and one lot of roughly 3,200 pieces was visibly off shade. The factory first argued the variation was minor. Under controlled lighting against the approved reference, it was plain. The agreed tolerance was a colour difference of no more than 1.0 under the CMC (2:1) method, and the affected lot read between about 1.8 and 2.1.
We separated those 3,200 towels before packing. After reviewing its dyeing records, the factory decided that remaking them was more reliable than correcting finished towels. The lot was reproduced at the manufacturer’s expense and cleared only after it passed the agreed inspection. Readiness slipped by about six days, and the shipment that left was consistent.
The original sample was sound. The variation arose between sampling and bulk production.
Which test methods and tolerances should towel buyers specify?
First decide how the towel will be used. A retail towel and one made for repeated hotel laundering should not carry the same requirements. For terry towels I would normally agree testing to these methods.
- Mass per unit area (GSM): ISO 3801, where applicable.
- Washing procedure: ISO 6330.
- Dimensional change: ISO 5077.
- Colour fastness to washing: ISO 105-C06.
- Colour fastness to rubbing: ISO 105-X12.
- Surface water absorption: ASTM D4772.
As a starting point, a buyer might set GSM within ±5% of target, which for a 550 GSM towel is 522.5 to 577.5. Shrinkage of no more than 3% after a stated wash procedure is a reasonable target for some products, and colour fastness to washing of at least grade 4 on the grey scale is common. These are not universal limits. Buyer and manufacturer have to agree the requirement and the test conditions. A purchase order that says “550 GSM, good colour fastness” defines nothing.
What should you measure on Ne 30/1 combed cotton yarn?
For Ne 30/1 combed ring-spun yarn for knitting, one workable set of buyer targets is below. A result that suits one knitting application may not suit another, so treat these as a basis for discussion. They are not universal pass or fail limits.
- Count variation: within about ±2% of nominal.
- Evenness (CVm): around 12 to 13.5% or better, depending on the quality level needed.
- Breaking tenacity: about 16.5 to 18 cN/tex or better.
- Imperfections: a buyer-defined maximum, possibly around 100 to 150 per kilometre for thin places at −50%, thick places at +50% and neps at +200%, under agreed settings.
- Hairiness: held against an agreed reference report, on the same instrument and method.
ISO 2060 covers linear density, ISO 2062 breaking force and elongation, and ISO 16549 evenness. Ask for results from several production packages, since one cone can be unusually good, and agree the technical performance before comparing prices.
How many washes should a towel go through before approval?
For ordinary retail towels, look at performance after the first wash and again after several more. Five washes is a useful first comparison. For hotels and hospitals I would be more demanding, with a cycle that reflects their laundering, possibly ten or more washes for a first durability check.
After washing, check dimensions, weight, colour, absorbency, softness, linting, stitching and whether the borders have changed shape. A towel can look excellent when new and still be wrong for its job.
What should a written specification contain?
It should tell the manufacturer exactly what to make and how acceptance will be decided. If two people read it separately, they should understand the same requirement. For a towel order I would include these ten headings.
- Product type and end use.
- Fibre composition.
- Construction and target GSM.
- Finished dimensions and tolerances.
- Colour references and acceptable variation.
- Washing and dimensional-stability requirements.
- Colour-fastness and absorbency requirements.
- Finishing, stitching and appearance standards.
- Packaging, labels and carton markings.
- Sampling, inspection and corrective-action procedures.
For yarn, replace the towel items with count, spinning process, twist where relevant, evenness, imperfections, strength, elongation, contamination and package details. Give every important measurement a test method, and attach the approved sample or reference report to the order.
Which inspection terms should you agree before production?
With an unfamiliar supplier I prefer three stages: confirm the approved pre-production sample and requirements, check in process once enough has been made to judge consistency (for some orders around 20 to 30% of production), and inspect the finished, packed goods before shipment.
For finished textiles an ISO 2859-1 sampling plan can be used. A common starting point is General Inspection Level II with AQL 2.5 for major defects, AQL 4.0 for minor defects and no critical defects accepted. The exact plan has to be agreed for the order.
The agreement should also say who inspects, who pays for normal inspection, and who pays for sorting, remaking and reinspection when goods fail. In the towel case the lot was separated and remade before shipment, and the buyer was never asked to accept goods outside tolerance.
What is the difference between pre-production, production and shipment samples?
- A pre-production sample is what the manufacturer proposes to make. It fixes the approved construction, colour and finish.
- A production sample comes from the actual bulk run. It shows whether the factory is reproducing what was approved.
- A shipment sample is taken from the finished consignment. It is the buyer’s reference for what was packed.
With a new manufacturer, or a specification sensitive to variation, insist on a pre-production reference and a production or final-lot check. In the navy towel order the sample was right and most of the production was right. One dye lot was not, and only checking across lots found it.