Don’t judge Pakistan’s textile industry by the first factory you deal with
By Muhammad Shakil, Founder & CEO ·
Pakistan has a more developed textile industry than many international buyers realise. It covers spinning, weaving, dyeing, finishing, home textiles and garments.
A buyer can have one disappointing experience with a Pakistani supplier and conclude that the whole market has the same limits. I think that’s a mistake. The hard part is working out which mill suits your particular requirement.
Can two mills quote the same yarn and deliver different results?
Yes. A buyer needed about 16 tonnes of 100% cotton Ne 30/1 combed ring-spun yarn for knitting. We shortlisted two spinning mills in Pakistan. The first quoted $3.02 per kilogram and the second $3.14. On 16 tonnes that is a difference of about $1,920, enough for the buyer to ask why we recommended the dearer mill.
So we compared the test reports instead of the quotations. The cheaper mill’s sample showed a CVm of about 14.2%, against about 12.3% for the second mill. Total imperfections, measured under the same settings, were also clearly higher in the cheaper yarn.
The buyer ran both yarns on its knitting machines. The cheaper yarn caused more stoppages and visible faults in the fabric. The second mill’s yarn ran more consistently, and the buyer placed the order there.
Both mills had quoted 30/1 combed cotton yarn. On paper the product was identical. Twelve cents a kilogram doesn’t mean much if the yarn brings more waste, more downtime or quality claims.
What should you look for on a first mill visit?
I pay attention to four things.
- Machinery condition. A list of expensive machines impresses me less than seeing how they are maintained: cleanliness, maintenance records and whether the operators understand the process.
- The testing laboratory. In a spinning mill I want to see how count, evenness, strength, imperfections and contamination are measured, with results from real production lots and not only the best sample.
- Production planning. A mill with fifty tonnes of daily capacity may not have fifty tonnes free for your count. I ask what is already committed and how often the schedule changes.
- How management handles uncomfortable questions. When I ask about defects, rejected batches or late deliveries, I listen for what happened and what was done about it.
A good factory shows that it controls its process, including when something goes wrong.
Which kind of mill suits which order?
A large mill isn’t automatically the right one, and a small specialist isn’t automatically the wrong one. It depends on what you are buying and how you will use it.
- Large-volume standard cotton yarn: established spinning mills with stable production and enough raw material. Consistency and repeat capacity matter more than one very low price.
- Fine-count yarn: look at fibre selection, spinning equipment, preparation and laboratory results. Not every mill that makes 20/1 and 30/1 can make finer counts consistently.
- PC and CVC yarn: experience with blending matters most, for correct fibre percentages and even mixing.
- Institutional towels for hotels, hospitals and laundries: durability, dimensional stability, absorbency and repeatable quality come first.
- Premium retail towels: softness, pile appearance, shade consistency, finishing and packaging carry more weight.
What should you ask before choosing a manufacturer?
Start with one question: have you produced this exact specification commercially before? The actual requirement, not something similar. Then ask for the following.
- A recent test report and a sample taken from production.
- The minimum workable quantity and a realistic production schedule.
- For yarn, which quality parameters are measured routinely and how lot-to-lot consistency is controlled.
- For fabric, the machinery, finishing capability, achievable finished width, shrinkage tolerance and colour consistency.
- For towels, how GSM, dimensional change, absorbency and shade between dye lots are controlled.
- Whether the mill does the whole process or outsources any major stage.
- What happens if a lot fails the agreed specification.
If a manufacturer won’t discuss rejection procedures before the order, that tells you how hard the relationship may be later.
What goes wrong when you choose on price alone?
A buyer was comparing 500 GSM cotton towels for hotels. One manufacturer was about 8% cheaper than another. The sample was soft, the dimensions looked right and the buyer preferred it.
The buyer had not set a washed-dimension requirement. Under repeated laundering some towels changed dimension by around 6%, against the 3% the buyer had in mind. Nothing showed when the towel was new. The factory would have had to change its processing or remake the goods before they could be accepted, and the lower quotation no longer looked like a saving.
The price of a textile can’t be separated from what it has to do. A hotel towel has to survive the hotel’s laundry. Knitting yarn has to run on the knitting machines. What you are paying for is how the product performs in use.
Does the same apply outside Pakistan?
Yes. A manufacturer in China may be very competitive in polyester filament yarn and have little experience with a particular spun-yarn construction. In India one cotton spinner may be strong in conventional counts while another is better equipped for fine combed yarn. The same holds in Indonesia, Thailand and Vietnam.
A country’s reputation tells you where capability exists. It doesn’t tell you which factory is right for your order. That is one reason Zeplar works with manufacturing partners in several Asian markets, and why one unsuccessful supplier should not define a country’s textile industry.